Page 1 of 1

Harald 18.2 or 16.1?

PostPosted: 10 Jan 2021 16:15
by Ilya
Hey
Ask for Harald and other
16.1 or 18.2 was broke in this situation
IMO was violated 16.1, because Perla very fast cahge course and not give me chance for avoid
Time reaplay 14:00

Re: Harald 18.2 or 16.1?

PostPosted: 10 Jan 2021 16:42
by Ilya
Ilya wrote:Hey
Ask for Harald and other
16.1 or 18.2 was broke in this situation
IMO was violated 16.1, because Perla very fast cahge course and not give me chance for avoid
Time reaplay 14:00

Re: Harald 18.2 or 16.1?

PostPosted: 10 Jan 2021 19:25
by Jean-Luc Dellis
Hi Ilya and all,
IMO its a 18.2 because mark-room involves room to round the mark as necessary and 43.1(b) exonerates Perla for any 16 breache.
Cheers,
Jean-Luc

Re: Harald 18.2 or 16.1?

PostPosted: 11 Jan 2021 16:10
by euphoria
Hi all,

Agree with Jean-Luc. As long as Perla is sailing within the mark-room he is entitled to, he is exonerated from breaking rule 16.1.
And well done to Jean-Luc for referring to the new rule number for exoneration in the latest official racing rules of sailing :-).

Harald