VSK Match Forum

use this for Protests !

RPC Info for all: wrote:• Dont discuss protests between races, but discuss them after all 7 races are done.
• If you don't agree on a protest or don't have time to discuss right after racing, post the protest in the RPC forum.

Server 2 race 2, we (red) have 3 Protests:

1.) 5:43, canceled 11 from dimitry
2.) 8: 25 is a 16.1 in our opinion. nuuk did the bestr to keep clear, I couldnt do more
3.) 9:57 dimitry cancled a right 18.2

.....

Dimitry, can you have a closer look on the situation and give your input?
Cheers, Holger

writing time is nice but can you show the video?

The replay is good enough and it is attached!

Holger

so you put it as you fall protests

Rc-Skipper Cancel 11 on 12:15 replay
P11

I sailed with Peppino and you with Joker.

Holger

See all carefully repeat:
1.) 5:43, canceled 11 from dimitry (On replay no contact)
2.) 8: 25 is a 16.1 in our opinion. nuuk did the bestr to keep clear, I couldnt do more(This is clear 11)he eschewed
3.) 9:57 dimitry cancled a right 18.2(on replay no contact)

we may need an extern person to help out!

Thx for this RPC anyway

Greetings,
Holger

when it will be solved? and simply repeat a close look ..

Rc-Skipper left you can see the replay and I just do not see how it is put

Defense for Protest from Team Blue in Race 1 Server 1
Imo there was a plenty of time to react for Eandavour, and my 16.1 should be exonerated.

If you see the Screenshot, where i hail RTT, there we are with comfortable distance to the obstruction, if you follow then the video you will see as well, that i have not tacked immediately. But in that moment as i tacked to avoid the obstruction, Endeavour is able to react immediately and forced the contact.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z8qsx2vg ... e=youtu.be

Dmitriy wrote:Rc-Skipper left you can see the replay and I just do not see how it is put

I talk about the race 2 on server 2: Peppino / nuuk vs. dimitry / Joker. Also this replay is attached. Watch my first post.

Holger

R1 Endeavour vs. Fix oder NIx

replay time: 3:22

Fix oder Nix tacked clear before Endeavour. There is much space between Fix oder Nix and Peppino after Fox oder NIx's tack.
Fix oder Nix hailed rtt and Endeavour did not write anything like "You tack".
So, Fix oder Nix did not wait for Endeavour's answer. ---> 20.1(b)(c)

Fix oder Nix tacked very early and creates contact with Endeavour.
Fix oder Nix had the possibility to duck and was not compelled to tack, imo, because there is still lots of room to react for Fix oder Nix.
He did not give Endeavour room to keep clear. ---> RRS13

I dont know, if rtt-hail was in time. from my point of view, it was not, but don't have anything to proof it.

To sum up:

1.) 5:43, canceled 11 from dimitry.
Fact is that there cant be a green flaq. We are agree. Fact is, that you (dimitry) caused the contact. Peppino was row, so I dont know why you dont accept the 11. By the way: Peppino did his turn, but he still wrote P.
2.) 8: 25 is a 16.1 in our opinion. nuuk did the bestr to keep clear, I couldnt do more.
IMO I cant do more. I really did my best to keep clear. -> 16.1 (By the way, I did my turn)

3.) 9:57 dimitry cancled a right 18.2
I know you as a skipper who know the (basic) rules. Why you cancel this pen? It was clear 18.2, which you cancelled!

Best regards,
Holger