SAM(thinkinghard) x PARUS - race 7 (replay time 8:48)
The situation:
Both boats on downwind startboars arriving to mark -
sam is windward
parus leeward
sam gets overllap 08:41:40
parus luff more breaking 17.1 at 08:46:00
sam
Moderator: VTC Race Committee
jiel wrote:Shura, it is not the right video for SAM/PARUS.
Concerning JIEL/PARUS my protest and opinion is that Parus luffed hard to keep clear of Jiel but failed. Jiel had to keep clear from Masino and gave room to Parus who had to luff softly to keep clear. Parus penalyzed 11.
samuel wrote:sam gets overllap 08:41:40
LG07 wrote: I would say green, because even if overlap was broken IMO Parus is in the limits of "proper course" to have a good rounding with optimal exit to upwind.
samuel wrote:I understand, thats could be centanly a hard case to umpire real and probably green, but we are on virtual sea with hightech in our favor. So to me is the best way to leave no doubt.
jiel wrote:case 1 : In an other recent case I suggested to use the "uncertainty principle" but a picture evidence was used to state an overlap which was little imo.
case 2 : Charles, my turn to repeat : I had to keep clear from Masino, so any course change of any skipper must be undertaken smoothly. Now if you think, I could bear away to give room to Parus, ok its a 15 for me.
Return to Team Racing Cup - Official Protests
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 26 guests