Lorenzo
I think Tiger no had way to pass behind boat on right side
Exactly, that's what i am pointing at.
Holger:
Why u just did not try to go behind?
By deliberately breaking rrs 11?
Holger:
Maybe you saw that posibility too late?
At which time you saw that possibility in the replay?
But to Protest because of a tactical mistake is not that good.
With mistake you mean avoiding contact, keeping clear by tacking when there is no other way without creating collision?
If u had tried to go behind, Stalker still gave you room, or not (which caused to a penalty)
Again, in this situation it would have meant bear down, ramming another boat, breaking rrs 11 (and rrs 14) intentionally, a sailing style i thought one should avoid.
If TR Call D10 does not apply here please explain why not? What are the differences?
Answer 2
In this case, it is clear to X that B will not give room. X complies with rules 11 and 14 by tacking.
B and X are overlapped when they are at the obstruction and rule 19.2(b) requires B to give X room between her and the obstruction. Penalize B as she fails to give room.